We could eventually utilise cookies and may need access to some of your browser settings. Click the following button if you agree with our data protection terms according to EU regulation 2016/679 (GDPR). We never ask nor store any of your personal data when using our website in a regular way.

Details >

    

Brilliant Consultants

About Wirecard's financial auditors and the chess game
Twitter Facebook Email Print     PDF 
Listen to this article
Brilliant Consultants

According to a legend from India, there was once a king in whose lifetime the chess game was invented. The king was so enthusiastic about it that he invited the inventor to his castle to grant him a wish. The inventor was a clever man and thought for a while, until he pointed to the chessboard in front of the king. He suggested he would like to have grains of rice, one on the first field, twice as much on the second, on the third double the amount of rice of the previous one, each square doubling the one before, until the 64th field of the chess board was reached.

The king was impressed by the man's modesty and granted his wish without considering that the cosmic sum of 18 quintillion, 446 quadrillion, 744 trillion, 73 billion, 709 million, 551 thousand and 615 grains of rice had accumulated on the 64th board square - the equivalent of 376 million and 80 thousand trains each with 30 railroad cars full of 30 tons of rice each. Or roughly 433 times the world rice production in 2018. That's how the king lost his entire kingdom to the man.

Good virtual cards

1

Wirecard is finally listed as a stock corporation on Germany's TecDax index in 2005, is one of the first to invent virtual credit cards. The company announced in 2005 it would acquire Berlin-based XCOM Bank AG for 18 million Euros. Munich auditors from Console5H GmbH, who rename themselves to RP Richter GmbH a few years later, sign off the financial reports from the start.

RP Richter and EY

2

In mid-2008, the SdK Group complained about Wirecard's balance sheets for 2007, especially with regard to Wirecard's takeover of Trustpay International AG. Wirecard commissioned Ernst & Young with a special audit for 2007. EY presented their findings at the end of 2008 with no impact on the 2007 reports. Wirecard's board chairman sells 10% of his Wirecard shares in mid-December 2007 and becomes a double millionaire, steps down from his position only 6 months later.

Visa and Mastercard

3

Mastercard and Visa imposed fines of several millions for money laundering transactions in 2008 and 2009 on Wirecard. Founder Schlichtegroll leaves the supervisory board in the Fall of 2009, is replaced by Stefan Klestil in December 2009. Klestil's stepmother Margot is appointed as ambassador to Moscow, Russia in 2009 as well, where she would remain until 2014, the year of the Winter Olympics in Sochi. In 2010, the allegations of GoMoPa regarding money laundering activities in Florida and Wirecard UK were dealt with at a supervisory board meeting 'with the appropriate countermeasures'.

Munich and Singapore

4

Wirecard's 2007 financial report was never corrected. Instead, SdK employees and short sellers were indicted and some sentenced to serve prison terms in Munich Stadelheim facility. A number of lawsuits against Wirecard accumulated from 2014 on, most of which ended to Wirecard's advantage. Marsalek would become COO on February 1, 2010. In 2016, EY's auditors signed forged receipts for credit balances at a bank in Singapore and recommended Wirecard's management the use of trust accounts in Asia.

Stuttgart and EY

5

CFO Ley resigns surprisingly in mid-2017. In 2018, the Zatarra report explains Wirecard's corrupt business activities in Asia. For 2019, EY's auditors initially accepted falsified receipts for 1.1 billion euros in trust accounts. After Wirecard's filing for bankruptcy, a lawyer from Stuttgart collects lawsuits especially against EY, he dies on a bicycle tour in spring 2021. The final report of the investigative committee in Berlin was unsuccessfully attempted to be prevented from publication, the special report about EY remains secret because of EY's legal efforts.


In a not so unsimilar way, the one or other financial auditor of the top consulting firm Ernst & Young (EY) seemed to have set out to propose financial advise to the German king company Wirecard, which in September of the same year 2018 replaced Commerzbank on Germany's DAX king stock exchange. For companies listed on Germany's largest stock exchange, there is the great responsibility for the correct preparation of financial data, which have to be presented to investors and to the public in great detail every three months, and at the end of each year. While one rarely hears about the meticulous accounting work assembled at most companies, things were entirely different with Wirecard, this actually long before 2018.

2005

One would have to start around the year 2005, when Wirecard completely absorbed the Berlin-based company InfoGenie AG, finally finding itself as a stock corporation listed on Germany's TecDax. Professional help with the many financial reports was initially sought from Munich-based auditing firm Control5H GmbH, whose auditors Roland Weigl and Ulrich Burkhardt signed the balance sheets for Wirecard already from the start.

In 2005, Wirecard was apparently one of the first to invent the so-called virtual credit cards, available only in electronic form and used for payments on the Internet. Many corporate customers were attracted and became Wirecard clients in the coming years. The same year, Wirecard announced to take over Berlin-based XCOM Bank AG for 18 million euros, a bank that had obtained a license from Visa and Mastercard to issue credit cards.

2006

Wirecard's 2006 annual report states on page 44 that a little more than 5 million euros was spent as acquisition costs for XCOM Bank AG. Additionally, another 18 million euros was spent for a (or their) somewhat obscure “customer portfolio consisting of a customer base of various types of European Internet service providers, 11 million euros in cash plus 1.3 million Wirecard shares”, and also a somehow “variable component of up to 17 million euros paid in the form of a debtor warrant”.

Shareholders did not seem to have complained much, except perhaps Fidelity International Limited in the Bermuda Islands, whose Wirecard voting rights fell to 2.88 per euro cent according to the 2006 report. As usual, Control5H's auditors Weigl and Burkhardt signed off without raising any issue for the 2006 financial year. All fine.

2007

The following 2007 annual report shows that Wirecard had its first and important growth spike in that business year. The share value almost doubled, so much that then supervisory chairman Klaus Rehnig sold around 10% of his Wirecard shares in mid-December 2007, making him a double millionaire at least. It is unknown whether wife Tanja also sold parts of her Wirecard shares at that time. She held with 2.83% a slightly higher stake in Wirecard than her chairman husband (2007 annual report, page 99).

2008

Only a few months later, the first serious complaints about the financial audits by Control5H GmbH, who renamed themselves to RP Richter GmbH in that time, surfaced. The 2008 Wirecard annual report states the following on page 187:

The investor protection association Schutzgemeinschaft der Kapitalanleger e.V. (SdK ) has raised an action to challenge the resolutions adopted at the Annual General Meeting concerning a discharge of the Management and Supervisory Board as well as a petition for a court order to have the annual financial statements of the Company for fiscal 2007 declared null and void....This action is still pending in the first [court] instance without a final judgement yet.

(Wirecard 2008 Annual Report, page 81 & 187)

Further details in the 2008 annual report on page 20 show that at the end of Wirecard's general meeting on June 24, 2008, the Protection Association of Investors (SdK) publicly complained about the financial statements, most likely relating to the comments by blogger 'memyselfandi007' on the WallStreet-Online internet forum. These complaints urged Wirecard's supervisory board to initiate a special audit for 2007 by Ernst & Young (EY), who from then on were situated next to RP Richter GmbH's auditors. In particular, the circumstances of Wirecard's TrustPay International AG takeover in 2007 had to be reconsidered, as the supervisory board itself states in the 2008 annual report on page 14.

In August 2008, these issues were discussed at another supervisory board meeting. In October 2008, EY auditors were asked to provide an explanation of SdK's complaints. Astonishingly however, EY's findings had no influence on the previously prepared financial data for 2007:

Prior to its meeting in October 2008, the Chairman of the Supervisory Board and the Board of Management requested the auditors from Ernst & Young to provide an explanation of the findings of their audit. In the process, individual items were discussed but which had no material impact on the meaningful nature and correctness of the consolidated financial statements and the consolidated management report for 2007. On the whole, there were no indications of any misleading statements in the consolidated financial statements and consolidated management report for 2007.

(Wirecard 2008 Annual Report, page 14)

There were side effects, however: Klaus Rehnig, until then chairman of the supervisory board and millionaire at least since the end of 2007, steps down from his position at the general meeting on June 24, 2008. He is succeeded by Wulff Matthias. The many global funds and companies that invested into Wirecard and were listed on page 73 of Wirecard's 2008 annual report did not seem to bother much.

Now that Wirecard could operate with their own Wire Card Bank, business was in full swing, especially in online gambling. So much so that credit card company Mastercard imposed a fine over 11 million British pounds on Wirecard in 2008 for labelling many financial transactions with incorrect transaction codes, according to Mastercard.

2009

Visa also filed a complaint with Wirecard about their shady retailers only one year later at the end of 2009. When these for Wirecard highly profitable retailers only changed their business names, but not their transaction volumes processed via Wirecard, the US imposed a fine of 12 million US dollars via a related lawsuit.

The two anglo-american top payment providers Visa and Mastercard had probably become aware of the shooting star from Germany meanwhile, and wanted to clear the fronts in the global payment market early on with these fines. Wirecard would not visibly mention these fines in any of their final reports.

Quite possible that during this time an exorbitant rejection of all anglo-american had established itself in Wirecard's top management level. This rejection may have been one of the reasons why not only literally all of Germany's financial supervision authorities were affected, but even the criminal prosecutors in Munich, who from then on - and especially about a decade later - preferred to rather go after investigative journalists and fraud detectors, than investigating Wirecard.

It is worth mentioning that co-founder and ex-porn operator Paul Bauer-Schlichtegroll leaves the supervisory board on October 31, 2009 (Wirecard 2009 Annual Report, page 66). As of December 10, 2009, his successor is Stefan Klestil, son of former Austrian President Thomas Klestil, who passed away in 2004. In 2009, son Stefan would not only become a member of Wirecard's supervisory board, but his widowed stepmother Margot Klestil-Loeffler is also appointed to the position as ambassador to Moscow, Russia, where she would represent Austrian interests until 2014, the year of the Winter Olympic Games in Sochi. The many gigantic construction projects in Sochi in that timeframe were realised also with the help of Austrian construction giant Hochtief, where Russian entrepreneur and oligarch Oleg Deripaska increased his shareholder stake significantly early on.

2010

Jan Marsalek is appointed to Wirecard's top management team on February 1, 2010, succeeding Rüdiger Trautmann as COO. At its meeting in April 2010, the supervisory board dealt with the "accusations made against the Wirecard Group, published inter alia on the GoMoPa website" with regard to the money laundering case involving Michael Schütt in Florida and Wirecard UK. "Appropriate countermeasures" were initiated, according to board chairman Wulff Matthias (Wirecard 2010 Annual Report, page 17). In detail, this meant that GoMoPa first corrected the whistleblower statements on their website, only to retract them later entirely; further that the public prosecutors in Munich investigated GoMoPa instead of seriously going after Wirecard's involvement in the money laundering case.

The auditors from EY along with those from RP Richter GmbH jointly undersign the annual report for 2010. Interestingly, that annoying problem with the 2007 financial statements and Wirecard's Trustpay AG takeover still had to be mentioned, also in the year before by the way:

As stated in the group management report, an action for annulment of the annual financial statements for fiscal year 2007 of the parent company Wirecard AG as well as an action contesting two shareholder meeting resolutions passed in 2008 relating to the exoneration of the management board and the supervisory board of Wirecard AG were lodged. To this effect, the Munich I Regional Court engaged an appraiser in 2009. The proceedings are still pending.

(Wirecard 2009 Annual Report, page 209; 2010 Annual Report, page 225)

2011

Things would be entirely different from 2011 on. Even though Wirecard's annual report mentions that EY was paid 433,000 euros for their financial audit for that business year (Wirecard 2011 Annual Report, page 232), all of a sudden the auditors from RP Richter GmbH would not appear any longer in the final report, also not in the years to come. While the financial auditors themselves had undersigned Wirecard's annual balance and financial sheets in the years before, they would from now on only be approved and personally undersigned by CEO Dr. Markus Braun, CFO Burkhard Ley and COO Jan Marsalek.

Wirecard's 2011 annual report also states that the Protection Association of Investors (SdK) lawsuit against Wirecard had ended, and that changes for the 2007 financial statements and reports were not necessary:

The suit filed by the Schutzgemeinschaft der Kapitalanleger e.V. (SdK) concerning, among other issues, the annual financial statements (single-entity financial statements) of the company for fiscal year 2007, has been legally ended. The ruling neither results in changes to the financial statements (consolidated or single-entity financial statements), nor does it impact the Company's financial position and results of operations.

(Wirecard 2011 Annual Report, page 155)

The 2007 financial reports were never corrected. On the contrary, Munich's public prosecutors would indict SdK employees and short sellers for their more than justified complaints also against Wirecard's 2007 financial reports, convict a few and even had some imprisoned in Munich's Stadelheim facility for 18 months.

2012 - 2015

For the work on the 2012 financial audits, EY received around 150,000 euros more than for the audit of the previous business year (Wirecard 2012 Annual Report, page 213). The jump in salary was worth the effort, it seems. In the following years, Wirecard grew rapidly, particularly through their Asia businesses.

Wirecard's 2013 annual report mentions only two legal proceedings against the company on page 124. A year later, the 2014 annual report states on page 134 that all pending proceedings are processed either by Munich's Regional Court I or Munich's Higher Regional Court. The lawsuits against Wirecard usually drag on for years, until after an opposing party's complaint, appeal or revision the proceedings usually end with an agreement of both sides, or to the benefit of Wirecard in these years.

Wirecard's 2015 annual report states that at least six legal proceedings are pending against the company, plus an unspecified number of smaller proceedings. Loosing any of these cases would be "extremely unlikely", according to Wirecard (2015 Annual Report, page 146).

2016

EY's auditors are getting particularly creative in 2016. Wirecard's business in Asia was done via partners there who needed securities for their business activities. Apparently, EY auditors themselves recommended to Wirecard's top management in a 2016 proposal the use of trust accounts, where the alleged third party business partners' profits would be safeguarded.

In mid-June 2016, Wirecard decided to expand the Supervisory Board and appoints Tina Kleingarn and Vuyiswa M'Cwabeni as new members (2016 Annual Report, page 15). The report also mentions that in 2015 at least three lawsuits were opened against Wirecard and in 2016 at least two. These are each described without exception as, quote: "Wirecard AG believes that losing this case is unlikely" (2016 Annual Report, page 151 & 152).

Most likely, these lawsuits were the result of complaints about Wirecard's Asia businesses. For the 2016 financial reports, EY's auditors accepted counterfeited documents of Wirecard's obscure trustee by the name 'Citadelle Corporate Services', according to which 86 million euros would allegedly lay in trust accounts at a Singapore bank. The counterfeited receipts were submitted as PDF documents with forged stamp and signature. EY signed off.

2017

In June 2017, Wirecard's supervisory board "intensively discussed the possible candidates for the position of CFO" Burkhard Ley, who apparently announced his resignation rather surprisingly (Wirecard 2017 Annual Report, page 13). For the year 2017, Wirecard names five legal proceedings against itself, as usual believes that "loosing the case is unlikely", also points out that "the risks of an immaterial impact on assets, financial position and results of operations arising from the current litigation cases cannot be completely excluded" (2017 annual report, page 167 & 168).

2018 - 2019

In 2018, Matthew Earl's famous Zatarra-Report was published by stock market letter maker and short seller Fraser Perring, which shed light on the financial scandals surrounding some Wirecard takeovers in Asia. Wirecard files a criminal complaint against this report, a criminal investigation of the British short sellers was opened by Munich's public prosecutors. Wirecard's former Asia Managing Director Pav Gill meanwhile had contacted Financial Times journalist Dan McCrum as a whistleblower, who published a number of reports from early 2019 on, at the beginning focusing on Wirecard's dubious Asia businesses.

On February 8, 2019, police raided the Singapore offices of Wirecard Asia-Pacific. Ten days later, Germany's financial supervisory authority BaFin declared a short sale ban on Wirecard's falling shares for 8 weeks to save what apparently could no longer be saved. At the end of 2019, KPMG is appointed to launch a special audit for the fiscal year 2019, commissioned by Wirecard when Financial Times and other journalists continued to report.

For the 2019 financial reports, EY's auditors had already taken into consideration Wirecard's written confirmations of 1.1 billion euros in trust accounts in Asia without much hesitation. On these documents, both account numbers as well as bank information were missing. EY's auditors at Wirecard's Munich headquarters were also not worried much about the German date notation on these foreign documents.

2020 - 2021

EY would refuse to sign the 2019 financial audit only in the year 2020. On June 18, 2020, Wirecard announced that 1.9 billion euros on trust accounts in the Philippines were simply missing.

After Wirecard's filing for bankruptcy, a well-known German lawyer from near Stuttgart took the complaints of many deceived Wirecard shareholders and focused his legal compensation efforts on EY's auditors. When the lawyer went on a bike tour on a weekend in the spring of 2021, he suddenly had a heart attack and passed away a little later in a hospital.

In 2021, an EY management and consulting partner who calls himself a "forensic" is invited as a witness to the Wirecard investigational committee in Berlin. The management consultant and psychologist stated there among other that "Jan Marsalek was a super eloquent jackass of all trades" who acted "partly brilliantly".

A little later, EY tried to prevent the publication of the final report of the Wirecard committee in Berlin by the filing of a lawsuit. An EY auditor wanted to have the references to his name erased in the report, and hence tried to hold back the entire 2000-page Bundestag committee report publication. EY's lawsuits were not only rejected by Berlin courts, but also by Germany's Federal Court of Justice (BGH) here.

The report of a special investigator however, commissioned by the Wirecard investigational committee solely to shed lights on EY's role in the Wirecard scandal, is successfully withheld from a publication by EY's efforts. The case was decided in favor of EY by Germany's Federal Court of Justice (BGH) in mid 2021. Not necessarily because of EY's concerns, but because the Bundestag committee had to file their claims against EY only after the committee's work had officially and legally ended.

The courts in Stuttgart meanwhile, EY's headquartered home in Germany, refuse to deal with the many angry investor lawsuits there and referred all compensation proceedings to the courts in Munich.


Will the humble wish for a grain of rice, doubled on every square of the chessboard, be granted there at last ?









 
by Martin D., an accredited and independent, investigative journalist from Europe. He holds an MBA from a US University and a Bachelor Degree in Information Systems, worked as a Consultant in the US and in the EU, and is currently writing on a book on how the mainstream media turned into a radical political player.
Leave a comment:



Send

Email Twitter Facebook Print


For tips and confidential information: send us your fully encrypted message at news@sun24.news by using our public PGP encryption key (online tool here).







Rate this article
    
Thanks !
or leave a comment
Send